Forums:
|
|
Technical Forum:
Computer Music Journal
Website: http://www.computermusicjournal.org/
Non-Technical Forum:
Gizmodo
Website: https://gizmodo.com/
Founded in 1977, the Computer Music Journal is a forum that publishes material related to the applications of electronics to music. Published by MIT Press and released on a quarterly basis, it covers a vast array of topics concerning electroacoustic music and audio digital signal processing. The authors of this peer-reviewed journal include scientists, engineers, and university professors; the chief editor is currently Douglas Keisler, an engineer with a PhD from Stanford University. Each release is between 80 and 128 pages long, while articles are around 10 pages long.
Gizmodo, on the other hand, is owned by Univision Communication and was founded in 2002; it is an online news forum that focuses on articles concerning technology. With many articles published daily, the forum covers many topics related to all aspects of modern technology. Gizmodo was created by Peter Rojas, holder of a master's degree in English Literature. Authors of news articles on this site don't seem to require credentials; they mainly only need the ability to write well.
While both of these forums focus on topics concerning technology, they are completely different in terms of their intent and readership. The journal originally came into existence to fill a demand that was brought about by the rise of electronic music making machines in the late 1960s and 1970s, while Gizmodo is more modern and simply fills the demand for interesting, light news entertainment on the subject of technology. Whereas the computer music journal is primarily intended for the sharing of information among the audio electronics engineering community with an end purpose of facilitating the development of new technology, Gizmodo is intended to casually educate members of the general public on technological matters. The journal is geared towards professional scientists, electronics engineers, and recording engineers; on the other hand, the news site is aimed at the mostly non-technical public with an interest in technology. In addition, the journal is highly respected as one of the leading publications in the field, while the news site is merely a casual news source with decent reliability. Furthermore, the journal doesn’t delve into politics and is neutral; the news site, however, has a somewhat liberal bent.
A further significant difference between the two is the material that they contain, particularly the level of technical complexity, the formality of tone, and the strictness of citations. The journal is highly technical, with advanced concepts including digital signal processing, control theory, circuit analysis, and others at the graduate and undergraduate level. With Gizmodo, mostly superficial theory is explained. The journal contains very technical equations, graphs, and diagrams as well as text analysis, whereas Gizmodo Articles contain pictures and videos in an online news site format in addition to text. With the journal, the text analysis has a formal tone and a lot of technical jargon; in contrast, with Gizmodo, the writing is very informal and upbeat. Journal Entries have a strict format involving titles and citations, and citations often include technical manuals and scholarly journal articles. On the other hand, Gizmodo is more loosely formatted; citations involved merely listing titles of works and include mainly non-technical books, articles, and videos.
The only noticeably similarity between these two forums is that their primary focus is on technology; otherwise, they are different in many ways. For example, the Computer Music Journal is written by scientists and engineers for their peers in the field of audio electronics and is very technical and formal, whereas Gizmodo is written by newspaper writers for the general public about technology and is much more vague and casual. Adherence to facts, peer review, and strict citations are critical to articles published in the technical journal; in contrast, the news website has a much looser system for fact-checking and references. Furthermore, the journal has a businesslike format and is mostly free of color, while the news website contains colorful images and videos. These forums are completely different, yet they both are well-suited for their respective goals and audiences.
Computer Music Journal
Website: http://www.computermusicjournal.org/
Non-Technical Forum:
Gizmodo
Website: https://gizmodo.com/
Founded in 1977, the Computer Music Journal is a forum that publishes material related to the applications of electronics to music. Published by MIT Press and released on a quarterly basis, it covers a vast array of topics concerning electroacoustic music and audio digital signal processing. The authors of this peer-reviewed journal include scientists, engineers, and university professors; the chief editor is currently Douglas Keisler, an engineer with a PhD from Stanford University. Each release is between 80 and 128 pages long, while articles are around 10 pages long.
Gizmodo, on the other hand, is owned by Univision Communication and was founded in 2002; it is an online news forum that focuses on articles concerning technology. With many articles published daily, the forum covers many topics related to all aspects of modern technology. Gizmodo was created by Peter Rojas, holder of a master's degree in English Literature. Authors of news articles on this site don't seem to require credentials; they mainly only need the ability to write well.
While both of these forums focus on topics concerning technology, they are completely different in terms of their intent and readership. The journal originally came into existence to fill a demand that was brought about by the rise of electronic music making machines in the late 1960s and 1970s, while Gizmodo is more modern and simply fills the demand for interesting, light news entertainment on the subject of technology. Whereas the computer music journal is primarily intended for the sharing of information among the audio electronics engineering community with an end purpose of facilitating the development of new technology, Gizmodo is intended to casually educate members of the general public on technological matters. The journal is geared towards professional scientists, electronics engineers, and recording engineers; on the other hand, the news site is aimed at the mostly non-technical public with an interest in technology. In addition, the journal is highly respected as one of the leading publications in the field, while the news site is merely a casual news source with decent reliability. Furthermore, the journal doesn’t delve into politics and is neutral; the news site, however, has a somewhat liberal bent.
A further significant difference between the two is the material that they contain, particularly the level of technical complexity, the formality of tone, and the strictness of citations. The journal is highly technical, with advanced concepts including digital signal processing, control theory, circuit analysis, and others at the graduate and undergraduate level. With Gizmodo, mostly superficial theory is explained. The journal contains very technical equations, graphs, and diagrams as well as text analysis, whereas Gizmodo Articles contain pictures and videos in an online news site format in addition to text. With the journal, the text analysis has a formal tone and a lot of technical jargon; in contrast, with Gizmodo, the writing is very informal and upbeat. Journal Entries have a strict format involving titles and citations, and citations often include technical manuals and scholarly journal articles. On the other hand, Gizmodo is more loosely formatted; citations involved merely listing titles of works and include mainly non-technical books, articles, and videos.
The only noticeably similarity between these two forums is that their primary focus is on technology; otherwise, they are different in many ways. For example, the Computer Music Journal is written by scientists and engineers for their peers in the field of audio electronics and is very technical and formal, whereas Gizmodo is written by newspaper writers for the general public about technology and is much more vague and casual. Adherence to facts, peer review, and strict citations are critical to articles published in the technical journal; in contrast, the news website has a much looser system for fact-checking and references. Furthermore, the journal has a businesslike format and is mostly free of color, while the news website contains colorful images and videos. These forums are completely different, yet they both are well-suited for their respective goals and audiences.
